This will hopefully be the first of many hotel reviews, and since I plan to do this more than once, I’m attempting to adopt a format that I can use for all future hotel reviews. I’ll be using the following criteria to give each hotel a ranking, on a scale of 1 to 10:
- Price
- Location
- Cleanliness
- Staff
- Amenities
- Comfort
Our first stop during our trip to Canada was in Toronto, and our home away from home for 3 nights was the Best Western Primrose, located at 111 Carlton Street, in downtown Toronto. We arrived on Tuesday, June 19th and checked out on Friday, June 22nd.
Price: We paid approximately $115 a night for our room with 2 double beds, and a street view. My mother paid $20 more per night, because she requested a room with a microwave and fridge. Upon checking in, my husband and I were also given a room with a microwave and fridge, and we weren’t charged any additional money for the upgrade. Overall, the price isn’t bad for a downtown hotel, but other factors, like cleanliness will, and DID affect how we viewed the price. Read on!
Location: We couldn’t have asked for a better location. For those of you who don’t know Toronto, Yonge Street is considered to be the backbone of the city. Walk north on Yonge Street and you’ll hit shopping and Bloor Street. Walk south and you’ll come to Eaton Center and the Hockey Hall of Fame. Our hotel was on Carlton Street, just about 3 blocks off Yonge - it was a very do-able walk, and if we didn’t want to walk, there was a metro station at the intersection of Carlton and Yonge we could go to. The hotel was in the so called “gay district”, and had 2 gay clubs within a block away, but we’re not offended by alternative lifestyles. I only mention it in case some are. The neighborhood felt safe, and there was a park (Allen Gardens)across the street where my husband jogged and took the kids to play. The old Maple Leaf Gardens was across the street, too.
Cleanliness: This is an older hotel, and it shows. While the lobby has been renovated at some point, the guest rooms we stayed in on the 6th floor had not been. The carpet was older, but in good shape, the bedding was a typical polyester hotel spread, and the bathroom…well, the bathroom had seen better days. While our room was clean enough, the bathroom had some mold issues in the shower grout, and the tile and grout was cracked and bulging away from the walls in some places. It was an unattractive bathroom, to say the least, and mold grosses me out.
Staff: Some of the staff was extremely friendly, like the concierge who booked our tour for us. Others…well, they could take us or leave us, and vice versa. For instance, a parking spot wasn’t available when we checked in, so we were told to use one of the public pay lots in the area. That’s ok - it’s just the manner in which this information was conveyed to us could have been a bit warmer and friendlier. We never saw our maid, but the room was done each day when we returned, and that’s all that matters to me.
Amenities: Where to begin? The pool is located on the 3rd floor, and gives you a nice view of the city. While the pool was large, the area around it for seating was extremely small - perhaps 4 feet on all sides. It was older looking too, and there was no slide. The kids enjoyed it, but it wasn’t a place to hang out for hours on end catching the rays. (Fine for the purposes of our trip!) You can see from the picture below that the area around the pool is just big enough for chairs and for one person to pass by:

While there was a restaurant in the hotel, there wasn’t any type of free breakfast offered. Thankfully, there was also a Tim Horton’s attached to the hotel, so we were able to find cheap eats each morning. While I’m on the subject of amenities, the hotel DID offer free wireless internet. The issue for me however, was that there was no outlet at the desk in the room. The only extra outlet was behind the bed, which mean moving the laptop to the nightstand between the beds to be charged. A small pain in the rear, but the free internet was nice.
Comfort: What bothers me the most about this hotel is that on the hotel website, it states:
Our newly renovated rooms offer all the conveniences of a luxury hotel, coupled with the conveniences of home.
Obviously, neither of the rooms we had for our group had been renovated, ever.
I also found this tidbit on the website:
Duvets with a 250 thread count are the standard at the Best Western Primrose
The picture of the guest rooms on the main page of the hotel website shows this image:

Lovely, isn’t it? Too bad our room looked nothing like it. I would have been quite pleased if it had. There’s nothing like a comfy bed with cushy white sheets and a duvet! However, our room looked like this picture found a bit deeper in on the website:

Those bedspreads leave a lot to be desired. And while I’m on the subject of comfort, the beds were not. The sheets were ill fitting, the pillows were lumpy, and the blankets were older and wash worn. The towels in the bathroom had seen better days as well. We “borrowed” more towels from the pool area so that’d we would have extra, but didn’t ever need them. I didn’t complain about the bedding issue while we were there, simply because I never saw the areas of the website I’ve referenced above. I certainly would have loved to have the duvets they feature and the renovated rooms mentioned!
I’m not really sure where to put the elevators, but they’re worth mentioning. It’s funny that in a city that has the CN Tower, with elevators speeding upwards at the speed of car, we stayed in a hotel with the slowest elevators I’ve EVER experienced. It became the joke during our 3 day stay. It wasn’t uncommon to wait for 5 minutes for one of the 4 elevators to come to our floor, or to the lobby.
The hair dryer also broke in our room after the first day. I was lucky that I always pack my own, and didn’t need it, but it just drove home the age of the hotel and the real need for updated rooms.
Overall rank: On a scale of 1 to 10, the Best Western Primrose in Toronto receives a 6. Had we stayed in a renovated room, I could see that rating going up, but sadly, we did not. The location was excellent, but I wouldn’t chose those hotel again if I were to go to Toronto, because there are simply so many other choices in the area. The bedding and bathroom were a big turn off for me, and the location and free internet access can’t make up for the run down feeling that our room had. As one traveler stated on Travelocity, if you’re looking for pampering and a high class feeling, this is not the hotel for you.